GMCA HOME MAIN PAGE Associations Directors Governance Laws & Statutes Issues
Newsletters Calendar Market Page Vendors Forum Report Card Archives Site Map Contact
LINKS PAGE Finance News Weather Government Directions Travel Dining Entertainment Search

This is a series of articles and updates related to the effort by the residents of Fort Lauderdale and surrounding communities to rescue their shrinking beach from the ravages of tidal erosion. The ramifications of our beach disappearing are staggering. The beach not only frames a wonderful "environment" in which our families live and thrive, it provides the financial wherewithall that supports our schools, maintains the civic necessities that nourish our neighborhoods, and is the single greatest protection for our coastal infrastructure from the ravages of storms and hurricanes! The articles are offered in chronological order. As such, they represent the historical progress of the project.

The US Army Corps of Engineers, Jacksonville District, has completed the Final Environmental Impact Statement for Segments II and III of the Broward County Shore Protection Project. They assert that the “proposed Broward County Shore Protection Project will be in the National interest and can be constructed while protecting the environment from unacceptable impacts.” Click Here to read the General Reevaluation Report with Final Environmental Impact Statement. The final Record of Decision is the last step with which the Army Corps of Engineers' participates in the process. It strongly recommends immediate implementation. Click Here to review the details of the FEIS or Click Here to understand the official Record of Decision. (Please Note: Requests to notify officials of your opinion regarding the Project should be considered in their relative temporal context!) To familiarize yourself with the details surrounding the overall history of how it came about, read on!


Shore Preservation


On April 30, 2002, more than 100 residents of Galt Ocean Mile (2 busloads) attended a hearing at the Hollywood Beach Community Center in support of the Army Corps of Engineers plan to renourish our shrinking beaches. The Galt Mile Community Association organized this expedition in response to anticipated opposition to the plan by certain politically motivated outside interest groups.

Severe Tidal Erosion
ONE HURRICANE AWAY?
As the least observant of us are already keenly aware, our beach is rapidly dwindling from the effects of natural erosion in the form of high winds (hurricanes) and tidal impact. Many of the buildings on the Galt have sacrificed large portions of their beach to this onslaught. Broward County's 24 miles of beach are uniformly under attack as the State of Florida has declared 21 miles of the county's beaches to be "critically eroded". Broward County has pledged nearly 50 million dollars to help mollify this impending disaster.

The county's plan divides the critical target area into three zones. The North Zone is about a mile of shoreline in Pompano Beach. The Middle Zone Includes the roughly 5 miles of beach running from Lauderdale-By-The-Sea to Fort Lauderdale Beach. The South Zone ranges from John U. Lloyd Beach State Recreation area for 6 miles through Dania, Hollywood Beach, and Hallandale Beach. The plan entails the Army Corps of Engineers supervise the pumping of sand dredged from seven areas north of Pompano Beach to the target zones after being transported by ship to the areas awaiting renourishment. This herculean effort will add in excess of 2.5 million cubic yards of sand to our shrinking beaches while widening them from 50 feet to 150 feet depending on the degree of need. The county anticipates recovering almost half of its outlay from the Federal Government.

There are several hurdles that require overcoming for this project to progress. They are environmental and political. Two areas of environmental concern center on the nesting habitat of the Sea Turtle and the general health of the coral reefs that line the barrier island. The Sea Turtle would benefit from the enlarged nesting areas that a widened beach would provide. The Coral Reefs were addressed in the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) developed by the Army Corps of Engineers to study the effects of the dredging upon the environment. The DEIS demonstrated that by carefully restricting the dredging zones and recognizing a substantial buffer between the dredge sites and the reef, the project could proceed with negligable (if any) adverse impact to the coral reefs. This information was publicly released and reviewed at the previously mentioned hearing at the Hollywood Beach Community Center on April 30, 2002. It was at this meeting that the 100 plus residents of Galt Ocean Mile in attendance learned about the OTHER obstacle to the project. The Broward County Department of Planning and Environmental Protection, while being congratulated for its efforts in saving our beach from extinction, came under attack from an organized assortment of outside interests who, despite claims of being indigenous, gave as their "home address" New York, Los Angeles, Cleveland, even The Bahamas.

Politics reared its heretofore faceless head. There are certain businesses that draw sustenance from unrestricted access to the reefs. Understandably, they seek to avoid any potential "down time" that this project would infuse into their balance sheets. There is also a radical group of environmentalists (as opposed to mainstream environmentalists, like most of the Galt residents) who feel that it would be beneficial if the people that inhabit the barrier island were to move to Tulsa! By placing their resources behind the faction that supports watching helplessly as the beach evaporates, they hope to delay or derail the project. They are actively garnering support from any political source seeking an opportunity to be "environmentally correct" absent the need to examine the facts assembled by Broward County and The Army Corps of Engineers.

The science that forms the basis for this project is what it is. The project was carefully planned, was determined to be safe, protects the environment, and enjoys widespread local support. The plans include the strict oversight warranted to ensure that the project is properly executed. The Shore Preservation Project protects our coral reefs, increases scarce nesting areas for the endangered Loggerhead, Green, and Leatherback Sea Turtles, and affords the human population a last opportunity to save the source of Fort Lauderdale's “lifesblood”, its beach. The widened beach will also provide additional storm protection for billions of dollars in property and thousands of lives. By "cherry picking" data from this issue, the opposition to rescuing the beach has introduced enough confusion to threaten the projects implementation.

From a fiscal perspective, consider this financial rationale. Broward’s beaches attract 7.2 million visitors a year, who spend $422 million annually in Broward County. Broward’s beaches contribute $548 million annually to Broward County’s economy, including the creation and sustenance of 17,700 full-time equivalent jobs in the County. Broward’s beaches add $1.4 billion to County property values. Our Broward beaches increase local government tax revenues by $29 million annually, of which the largest beneficiary is the Broward School District, which collects about $10 million annually in that regard. Broward’s beaches result in an $803 million annual input to southeast Florida regional economy, and create 26,000 jobs in the region. Out-of-State visitors to Broward’s beaches have a $598 million annual impact on the economy of the State of Florida, create 19,000 jobs in the State, and produce $19 million in annual State tax revenues. More than 60% of overnight tourists said that they would not have come to Broward County if there were no beaches, and a further 14.3 percent said they would come less frequently (Attention: those businesses that rely on unimpeded access to the coral reefs...how would a 75% decrease in tourist dollars affect your digestion?). Broward’s beaches protect over $4 billion in upland property, structures, and infrastructure. In Florida, beaches protect $150 billion in shorefront structures and infrastructure. Florida’s beaches alone contribute an annual increase of about a half billion dollars in Federal income tax revenues. Florida’s beaches attract 2 million international tourists, who spend about $1.1 billion annually in the State. Need I say more? If so, go to the Broward County Department of Planning and Environmental Protection, Biological Resources Division (Click Here) and verify this FIRST HAND!

We need to take a cue from this opposition. By firing copious correspondences toward a wide spectrum of issue-craving politicians, they were bound to gain some success. The project is on a judicial hold while the science is being "negotiated"??? It behooves us to draw to the attention of our representatives the depth of our concerns and the resolve of our convictions in view of the distinct possibility that at this time next year, Fort Lauderdale may not have a beach!

Stephen H. Higgins is the Beach Erosion Administrator for the Broward County Department of Planning and Environmental Protection (DPEP), Biological Resources Division, 218 S.W. 1st Avenue, Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 Phone: (954) 519-1265, Fax: (954) 519-1412. He is a staunch advocate of replenishing the beach and could use your support. The person managing this project on behalf of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers is Yvonne L. Haberer, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Jacksonville District, P.O. Box 4970, Jacksonville, Florida 32232-0019. You can also surf to the Report Card section of this site where you'll find ALL of your representatives. You might consider sending Governor Bush, Senator Graham, Senator Nelson, Congressman Shaw, Senator Atwater, Representative Bogdanoff, Representative Seiler, and Commissioner Scott a friendly E-mail letting them know how you feel! Once there, simply browse down to the representatives information section and click the E-mail link. Even easier, just click on the name under the representative's picture and WHAM...you're there!

Click To Top of Page


ISSUES MENU
Click on buttons below to review an issue.





Issues Home Page



Beach Renourishment Project

Stephen Higgins Update

Galt Mile Needs You!

GMCA Plan of Action

Broward Beach Coalition

Beach Renourishment Postponed

Governor and Cabinet Set to Vote

Broward Beach Plan Approved by Governor

Final Environmental Impact Statement

Final Record of Decision

Delays Over - Permit Received

Where's the Beach?

Hollywood Gets Sand

Broward Celebrates

Wilma Batters Broward Beaches

Turtle Magic

Outfall Pipes

Turtle-Safe Lighting

Start Sand Hunt

Bacterial Infestation Closes Beach



New Fire Safety Mandate



Cleveland Clinic Emergency Room



City of Fort Lauderdale Page



Budget Crisis Page



Broward County Business



Broward County Property Appraiser



Politics & Parlor Tricks in Tallahassee



AEDs - Sudden Cardiac Arrest (SCA)



Calypso Deepwater Port and Pipeline



32nd Street Alley



Fort Lauderdale/Galt Mile Crime Statistics




Search GMCA or the web
powered by FreeFind



Search GMCA Site
Search the Internet

Fort Lauderdale Beach

Hollywood Beach

Widened Nesting Grounds

Coastal Dynamics

Biological Reef Monitoring Fish Count

Transect Lines at a Broward County Reef Monitoring Research Site


Florida Department of Environmental Protection

Broward County Biological Resources Division

Broward County Department of Planning and Environmental Protection (DPEP)

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

Environmental Protection Agency

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

National Marine Fisheries Service

Going...Going...Going...
GOING...GOING...GOING...

Update: Stephen Higgins
Shore Protection Project


Stephen Higgins, the Beach Erosion Administrator for the Broward County Department of Planning and Environmental Protection (DPEP), Biological Resources Division, addressed a meeting of the Galt Mile Community Association’s Presidents Council on October 7, 2002 at the Ocean Club Condominium. Rose Guttman (President of the Ocean Club), Pio Ieraci (Presidents Council Chairman), and Robert Rozema (Galt Mile Community Association President) hosted Mr. Higgins for the purpose of providing Council members with an update to the Broward County Shore Protection Project.

Mr. Higgins advised the Council that the Galt Mile Community Association and the residents of the Galt Ocean Mile community played an important part in advancing the project in the face of significant organized opposition by certain political interests. In particular, the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) requirements warranted a public meeting in consideration of the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) developed by Broward County. Because there was insufficient public notification of this event, the only organized response to the Impact Statement would have been by a radical outside interest group representing themselves as beach residents whose intent was to derail the project. Two busloads of 100+ Galt Mile residents attended the meeting in support of the project. Hundreds more wrote letters affirming support. NEPA actually received over 900 comments in response to the DEIS coordination, about evenly split pro and con. This demonstration of "community will" effectively offset the months-long organized effort to topple the project and usurp the final opportunity to rescue the beach! The Galt Mile community effort helped put the Project back on track.

Ongoing negotiations with an assortment of environmental, civic, and governmental agencies have yielded substantial progress in addressing their concerns. Permits have been secured from the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) and are in process by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (ACE). In that it is a Federal project administered by Broward County, input from an assortment of Federal regulatory and resources agencies (i.e. the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the National Marine Fisheries Service, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, etc.) is necessary to achieve the maximum Federal and State contributions to a clean, long-lasting beach with attractive and productive marine environmental enhancements. Consideration for the sections north and south of Port Everglades are scheduled to transpire over the next two years. The Hollywood-Hallandale Beach segments of the Shore Protection Project should commence in the spring of 2003 and continue through the summer into early autumn. The renourishment will wend its way north, breaking for Sea Turtle season, to the Galt Mile community by November 2003. 200' sections of beach would be closed for a few days at a time as the project progressed. Completion is anticipated by March 2004.

Mr. Higgins also spoke to the concerns voiced by the Presidents of some Associations using outfall pipes that extend from their buildings into the shallow beach. The impending widening of the beach threatens to cover the terminus of the shorter versions of this pipe. He recommended that each affected building management check the size and current necessity of its pipe and contact his office for information and assistance. Since the ultimate length of the pipe will be contingent on the eventual size of the beach abutting each building, Mr. Higgins volunteered his good offices to address the subjective data needed for drains, wells, pipe lengthening, or alternative outfall system contingencies for individual Associations. While the cost ancillary to this adjustment isn't astronomical, the fact that it occurs in the midst of a neighborhood-wide renovation effort magnifies the fiscal pain wrought of any possible additional assessment. Then again, the beach is at stake...what choice do we have?

The contact information for Beach Administrator Stephen H. Higgins’ office at the Broward County Department of Planning and Environmental Protection (DPEP), Biological Resources Division is 218 S.W. 1st Avenue, Fort Lauderdale, Florida 33301 Phone: (954) 519-1265, Fax: (954) 519-1412. The E-mail address is shiggins@co.broward.fl.us. To read the entire history of the Shore Protection Project, Click Here.

Click To Top of Page


THE GALT MILE NEEDS YOU!
Shore Protection Project


The Galt Mile Community Association has been looking after the interests of our community for decades. We feel that we now face the most serious threat to our neighborhood and homes in recent history! The beach that is the focus of our lifestyle and the foundation of our TAX BASE is disappearing. The Broward County Department of Environmental Protection and the Army Corps of Engineers have developed a plan to renourish the beach that has passed muster with every MAJOR ENVIRONMENTAL GROUP (including the US Fish and Wildlife Service, the National Marine Fisheries Service, the Environmental Protection Agency, the US Army Corps of Engineers, Jacksonville District Regulatory Division, the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, the Broward County Department of Planning & Environmental Protection, etc.) and every GOVERNMENTAL INQUIRY! The plan is meticulously stringent in terms of protecting EVERY ASPECT OF THE ENVIRONMENT. The sea turtles, the coral reefs, and the native fish that populate our shoreline have been scrupulously provided for. THE PLAN IS COMPLETELY FUNDED AND READY TO BE IMPLEMENTED!

THE BOTTOM LINE: Every issue has its inherent pros and cons. The legitimate concerns of the environmental community had to be addressed. They rightfully insisted that the sea turtles and the coral reefs be protected from the exigencies of dredging and filling. THIS WAS DONE! The plan avoids disrupting the coral reefs and adds miles of additional beach that sea turtles utilize to lay eggs. As previously stated, the environmental community negotiated a SAFE EFFECTIVE PLAN. (For an in-depth analysis and the historical underpinnings of this issue CLICK HERE!)

HOWEVER...as in every group, the environmental community has a strong middle and the radical fringe! The only obstacle that remains to the rescue of our beach is this radical group of politically vested interests that, having lost EVERY SCIENTIFIC ARGUMENT, is trying to raise the costs involved by senselessly delaying the project! Every year the beach shrinks, it is more expensive to restore it. The funds are allocated, the scientific protections demanded by the mainstream environmental community are in place, and local support for the project is overwhelming! The Governor and his cabinet have postponed a Tuesday, January 28th meeting until March to ascertain the extent of that support. THAT MEANS US!

The GMCA Plan of Action

A representative of the Galt Mile Community Association is bringing a petition of support for this project to this important Cabinet meeting (see above). If we can demonstrate our concern for our beach with a substantial number of signatures of residents, THE PROJECT WILL CONTINUE UNABATED. Please care enough to WRITE YOUR NAME and stand up for saving OUR BEACH. PLEASE...SIGN THE PETITION that is posted in your building office or at your security desk (ask for it!).

The petitions are an important part of this campaign. They should be supported by DIRECT CONTACT as well. Please locate the “Letters of Support” in your building lobby or office. Attached to the "Letter of Support" is a "Contact List" containing the addresses, telephone numbers, FAX numbers, and E-Mail addresses of the various Cabinet Members and the Governor. Simply separate the “Letter of Support”, choose a “target” from the “Contact List”, sign your name at the bottom, and mail it in! Nothing To It!!!
ALSO...our representative’s words will carry more meaning if they are accompanied by a blizzard of positive supportive E-mails from our residents to the Governor and the Cabinet members.



Galt Mile Needs YOU!

Please Sign...Write...Send E-Mails...NOW!


Please take a moment RIGHT NOW to send E-mails to the Governor and the various Cabinet members and administrative personnel that need to know that we support the Broward County Shore Preservation Project. Following below is a list of these politicians and functionaries. Simply click on their E-Mail addresses and tell them that YOU ARE IN FAVOR OF THE BROWARD COUNTY SHORE PRESERVATION PROJECT CONTINUING WITHOUT DELAY! In Fort Lauderdale the beach is our spiritual center, our Tax Base, and the single greatest protection against life-threatening storms and hurricanes. Please send out as many as you can while you watch TV, while doing the laundry, or while gabbing on the phone! IT WILL MAKE A HUGE DIFFERENCE...THANKS!

You can also go to the Report Card section of this site to have easy access to ALL of our elected officials.

Please understand that this is not simply an issue of “diminished lifestyle”. The ramafications of our beach disappearing are staggering. The beach not only frames a wonderful “environment” in which our families live and thrive, it provides the financial wherewithall that supports our schools, maintains the civic necessities that nourish our neighborhoods, and is the single greatest protection for our coastal infrastructure from the ravages of storms and hurricanes! Click Here for VERIFICATION of this statement!

Multi-Mail The Cabinet!

LOOK...If you're not predisposed to send e-mails to all the addresses below...Just Click Here to send an E-Mail to Governor Bush, Commissioner Gallagher, Attorney General Crist, and Commissioner Bronson...all at once! Just Click Here and express your support for the Broward County Shore Preservation Project...Send it off...the E-mail will go to all four Cabinet Members, Senator Atwater, and Mayor Naugle!

The same “Multiple E-mails” can be sent to the Cabinet Staff of the various Cabinet members. Please Click Here to send E-Mails to all the appropriate Cabinet Staff personnel. Please send this second E-mail as well. With these two E-mails your voice will be heard in twenty different venues! What a deal...GRAB IT!

If you want to help but either don't know what to write, don't have the time to write, or don't know how to send an E-mail, simply type your name and your E-mail address into the form below and click "Send" to contact all the Cabinet Members and their staffs. If you make a mistake in entering your name or E-Mail address, press "Reset" and make the correction. If you want to alter, replace, or personalize the text of the “Message”, go right ahead!

Your Name

Your E-mail Address

Subject

Your Message

If your E-Mail program doesn't support Multiple Mail (most of them do)...GET A DIFFERENT E-MAIL PROGRAM! They're FREE...(i.e. Hotmail.Com)! Until you do, send as many of the individual E-Mails below as possible by clicking on the E-Mail addresses. There’s a lot at stake! Thanks!

Governor Jeb Bush, 210 The Capitol, Tallahassee, FL 32399
Write: PL 05 The Capitol, Tallahassee, FL 32399-0001
Phone: (850) 488-4441, 850/488/7146, FAX: (850) 487-0801
E-mail: flgov@myflorida.com or jeb.bush@myflorida.com
Cabinet Staff:
Colleen Castille
Phone: (850) 488-5152, FAX: (850) 488-9578
E-mail: castilc@eog.state.fl.us
Stephanie Culp FAX: (850) 488-5152
E-mail: culps@eog.state.fl.us or Stephanie.Culp@MyFlorida.com
Sherry Slattery FAX: (850) 488-5152
E-mail: slattes@eog.state.fl.us
Treasurer Tom Gallagher, Office of Cabinet Affairs, LL 27, The Capitol, Tallahassee, Florida 32399-0309 Phone: (850) 413-2825,(850) 413-3106, FAX: (850) 488-7265
E-mail: gallaghert@doi.state.fl.us
Cabinet Staff: 200 East Gaines Street Tallahassee, FL 32399-0309
E-mail: cabaff@doi.state.fl.us
Kevin Stanfield Phone: (850) 413-3106, FAX: (954) 413-2828
E-mail: stanfieldk@doi.state.fl.us
Gail Robinson Phone: (850) 413-2825, FAX: (850) 488-7265
E-mail: RobinsonG@dfs.state.fl.us
Agriculture Commissioner Charles H. Bronson, LL28 The Capitol, Tallahassee FL 32399
FAX: (850) 414-9778
E-mail: meltonc@doacs.state.fl.us or Hydep@doacs.state.fl.us
Cabinet Staff: Michele Myers FAX: (850) 410-6747
E-mail: myersm@doacs.state.fl.us
Attorney General Charlie Crist, PL01 The Capitol, Tallahassee, FL 32399-1050 OR
Cabinet Affairs - Office of the Attorney General (Monesia T. Brown, Director) The Capitol, Tallahassee, FL 32399-1050
Tel: (850) 245-0145, FAX: (850) 487-2564
E-mail: ag@oag.state.fl.us
Cabinet Staff: Kent Perez Tel: (850) 488-5152
E-mail: kent_perez@oag.state.fl.us
Diana Sawaya-Crane Tel: (850) 487-1963
E-mail: diana_sawaya-crane@oag.state.fl.us
Diane Moulton FAX: (850) 245-0184
E-mail: diane_moulton@oag.state.fl.us
Florida Senator Jeffrey H. "Jeff" Atwater FAX: (561) 842-6240
E-mail: atwater.jeffrey.web@flsenate.gov
Fort Lauderdale Mayor Jim Naugle
E-mail: mayorjames@aol.com

Click To Top of Page


The Broward Beach Coalition


The threat to our beaches has united concerned citizens, government, business, workers, and the environmental community in a partnership designed to alert our representatives to the disquiet precipitated by this impending disaster. The Broward Beach Coalition is a grass roots cross section of community interests that have conjoined to convey our concerns to the Governor and the Cabinet before they adjudicate this issue absent community input.

The Broward Beach Coalition Web SiteUnfortunately, when an issue (such as the beach disappearing) generates a heightened degree of concern in a community, it attracts the attention of political opportunists. The Coalition's intention is to dispel the unfounded speculations that have been promulgated in order to delay or derail this crucial project. Every claim made by the project’s opponents has been scientifically refuted or addressed in detail.

The Broward Beach Coalition Web SiteThis week the Coalition welcomed Linda Gill, Vice President of the Gill Hotels Company and Governor Bush’s appointee to the Florida Commission on Tourism, as Co-Chair to the Coalition's Board. Environmental activist Roy Rogers has also joined the Broward Beach Coalition as an outspoken advocate. Mr. Rogers has served as the Vice Chair of the Florida Audubon Society and Vice Chair of the Florida Community Trust. In addition, he Chairs the Nature Conservancy and is the Governor’s appointee to the Environmental Regulation Committee.

The Broward Beach Coalition launched a new web site http://www.browardbeaches.com as part of its campaign to shine light on this controversy by putting the issues involved in perspective. The information available is always fresh and authoritative. You can sign on to their contact list in order to be kept abreast of breaking news and participate in letting Tallahassee know how you feel! Click Here to check it out! After all…you've got a dog in this fight!


Governor & Cabinet Defer on Broward Beach
Coalition chairman
Pio Ieraci explains urgent need to officials


Governor Jeb Bush
GOVERNOR JEB BUSH
Tallahassee – Governor Jeb Bush and the Florida Cabinet were scheduled to consider advancing the Broward County Beach Renourishment Project on January 28, 2003. Due to a statutory gaffe, the agenda had to be postponed. A conflict between Florida law and the Florida Constitution forced the Governor and the Cabinet members to defer consideration of the Broward Beach Renourishment Project until the Florida Legislature changes the law to reflect the composition of the new cabinet.

Florida voters approved a constitutional amendment reducing the size of the Florida Cabinet from seven to four members. The law, which was not changed by the amendment, requires five votes to approve certain actions. Governor Bush will propose legislation to change the law when the legislature convenes in March.

Pio Ieraci
CHAIRMAN PIO IERACI
“Like all Floridians, the Broward Beach Coalition values the statutes of the State of Florida, and respects the decision by the Governor and Cabinet to defer a decision on the Broward County Beach Renourishment Project,” Broward Beach Coalition Chairman Pio Ieraci said. “We are grateful that the Cabinet took the time today to learn more about the need to preserve and renourish Broward’s beaches to protect public safety, enhance tourism, create jobs and grow business. We look forward to returning to expand on our position once the legislature has passed legislation to reconcile the law with the Constitution of the State of Florida."

Although the Governor and Cabinet deferred the decision on the Broward Beach issue, representatives in favor of the beach project were allowed to explain the need for moving the project forward to the Governor and Cabinet. “The beaches protect our community and the infrastructure of Broward County. The County’s plan allows for the protection of Broward County’s community and the protection of the environment. We will continue to ask you to protect our livelihoods, our families, our homes, and our businesses and approve the Broward Beach Renourishment Project,” Ieraci testified.

Representing the Broward Beach Coalition and speaking on behalf of the Broward Beach community included Pio Ieraci, Chairman of the Galt Mile Community Association’s Presidents Council, Christopher Pollock, President of the Greater Fort Lauderdale Lodging and Hospitality Association, Fort Lauderdale Assistant City Manager Bud Bentley, Hollywood Commissioner Keith Wasserstrom, Richard Sala, Executive Director of the Hollywood Beach Community Redevelopment Agency, George Zinkler, President of the Hollywood Beach Business Association, and Irwin Oster, Immediate Past President of the Hollywood Beach Civic Association.

Florida Cabinet
FLORIDA CABINET
The Florida Cabinet was scheduled to consider The Broward County Beach Renourishment Projecton on April 8, 2003 and a meeting of the Cabinet Aides was scheduled for April 2, 2003. The project was deferred again until May 13, 2003. The City of Deerfield Beach requested the deferral to accomodate a conflict in it’s Mayor’s schedule. The Deerfield Beach City Commission had scheduled a meeting on the same date as the April 8th Cabinet meeting. The Cabinet’s Agenda for May 13th will carry the renourishment project as will the May 7th meeting of the Cabinet Aides. The Cabinet Aides review the issues to be considered by the Governor and the Cabinet members for the purpose of accruing data and formulating recommendations.


Broward Beaches Face the Music
Governor and Cabinet Members to finally decide on Beach Rescue Effort


Chief Financial Officer Tom Gallagher
CFO Tom Gallagher
The future of Broward County lies squarely in the hands of The
Governor and the Cabinet. After months of delays and deferrals, some as a result of miscues that would befit an episode of the original Saturday Night Live (See Above), a final decision about the long-awaited beach renourishment is at hand. On May 13th (at 9 AM) Governor Jeb Bush, Attorney General Charlie Crist, Chief Financial Officer Tom Gallagher, and Agriculture Commissioner Charles Bronson will either rescue Fort Lauderdale’s disappearing shoreline or relegate the continued existence of Broward County’s beaches to the mercy of the next hurricane. While most casual observers would naturally assume that the State of Florida would never allow the beaches that underpin the State’s economy to disappear, the natives of Fort Lauderdale, Hollywood, Pompano, and the rest of Broward County are rightfully concerned. Even though the mainstream environmental community staunchly supports saving the beaches, the State government has given inordinate attention to several radical interest groups that have successfully delayed a project designed to accomplish this.

Attorney General Charlie Crist
Attorney General
Charlie Crist
Commissioner of Agriculture Charles Bronson
Secretary Charles Bronson
The Broward Beach Coalition, comprised of leaders of the environmental community, the business community, local government, and concerned citizens, was formed to respond to the overt attempt by lobbyists to sabotage the project for certain business interests. The Coalition has created a Web Site that addresses the legitimate concerns of the inhabitants of Fort Lauderdale and Broward County. Coalition environmentalists have written a letter supporting the beach renourishment project that every concerned resident and visitor can easily lend their name to. Please Click Here to go to the Broward Beach Coalition Web Site. Once there, feel free to peruse the factors that make this issue critically important. You can also send that pre-written letter of support for the project to the Governor and Cabinet members with one click (as many of your neighbors already have)!

These are some of the Environmental Groups that have given their approval to the Broward County Beach Renourishment Project:

Lobbyists exist to exploit the fact that politicians are susceptible to pressure. The most effective pressure resulting from an issue, however, comes from the affected community. Now is the time to send a message to the Governor and the Cabinet that we expect them to approve this completely safe, environmentally sound, and fully funded project to rescue the beach. Even if you have already sent a letter of support, signed a petition, or sent an e-mail during this campaign, clicking off one more letter (at the Broward Beach Coalition Web Site) is critically important. Long after the lobbyists return to Los Angeles, Cleveland, Boston, and the Bahamas, we will still be here. The question is, will our beach still be here? Answer that question by going to the Broward Beach Coalition Web Site to vote “YES” with a simple click...it will only take about 20 seconds and the results will be enjoyed by our great grandchildren!

A contingency of local politicians, neighborhood associations, environmentalists, and concerned citizens will attend the May 13th Cabinet meeting in Tallahassee to represent our interests in this critical agenda. GMCA Presidents Council Chairman Pio Ieraci had previously accompanied this collection of Mayors, Vice Mayors, County and City Commissioners, business and civic leaders, and environmental activists on a punishing series of fruitless round trips to Tallahassee only to learn that the issue had been deferred or postponed. As a result of the disappointing January 28th deferral of the Beach Rescue Agenda item, an understanding was arrived at that guaranteed its consideration at the May 13th Cabinet meeting. Even so, Mr. Ieraci’s fingers will remain crossed.

To get more information about the Broward County Beach Renourishment Project and/or assist in supporting this important effort, call the Broward Beach Coalition at (866) 658-9818 or contact them by e-mail at BBC_Info@browardbeaches.com. Please send an email to the Governor and the members of the Cabinet before they pass judgement on the Beach. It WILL make a BIG difference!

Now Its Your Turn

The Broward County Shore Preservation Project is scheduled to proceed in two segments. Segment III (3), to the south, is designed to repair Hollywood’s last gasp coastline (waves lap against seawalls where tourists and locals used to frolic). Segment II (2) attends to the roughly 5 miles of beach running from Lauderdale-By-The-Sea to Fort Lauderdale Beach. The project’s overall success depends upon the segments being accomplished in concert. Addressing Segments II (2) or III (3) alone is akin to fixing three of four broken legs on a chair. The Broward County Department of Environmental Protection and the Army Corps of Engineers agree that the project’s ultimate success is contingent on the problem being addressed as a whole. Each segment contributes to the overall stability of the shoreline.

Some bureaucrats, in an effort to compromise with the opponents of this project, have suggested that the Fort Lauderdale component of the project be “postponed”. This “compromise” is unacceptable. To ignore the scientific necessity, the inevitable financial devastation to the tax base, and the demands of millions of South Florida residents is unconscionable. Sacrificing Fort Lauderdale is not only unacceptable, it will disable the entire project.

The Governor and the Cabinet need to be made aware of our concern. Please take a moment to send an E-Mail to Governor Bush and Cabinet members Attorney General Charlie Crist, Chief Financial Officer Tom Gallagher, and Commissioner of Agriculture Charles Bronson. Inform them that the Broward County Shore Preservation Project should be implemented immediately and in its entirety. Indicate that you support commencing the Fort Lauderdale Segment II (2) renourishment ON SCHEDULE.

  • Click Here to E-Mail Governor Jeb Bush

  • Click Here to E-Mail Attorney General Charlie Crist

  • Click Here to E-Mail Chief Financial Officer Tom Gallagher

  • Click Here to E-Mail Commissioner of Agriculture Charles Bronson

    If you are pressed for time or can’t find the words to express your concern, simply fill in your name and E-Mail address and press SEND in the form below. Your message will be sent to the Governor and all the Cabinet Members. Please feel free to read the included text. To send a different message, use the E-Mail links above.

    BTW - This is a different message than the one posted earlier on this site, so even if you contacted the Governor previously...PLEASE DO IT AGAIN!

    Your Name

    Your E-mail Address

    Subject

    Your Message

  • Please take a moment...ITS IMPORTANT! We only have until May 13th to alert the Governor and the Cabinet to our concerns.

    Click To Top of Page


    Victory on the Beach

    Galt Mile Contingent Addresses Governor and Cabinet


    Pio Ieraci, Chairman of the Galt Mile Community Association’s Presidents Council, led a contingent of eight Galt Mile residents to Tallahassee in support of rescuing Fort Lauderdale’s disappearing beaches. As a result, the Broward County Shore Preservation Project finally received the long awaited green light from the Governor and the Florida Cabinet at the scheduled May 13th Cabinet meeting. Rose Guttman, Fern McBride, Kathleen Freismuth, Iris and Joe Anastasi, Ron Gresser, and Eric Peter Berkowitz met the Governor and the Cabinet wearing red tee shirts emblazoned with "Save Broward Beaches" in response to the unwarranted delays encountered by the project in Tallahassee.

    Former Director Steve Somerville of the Broward County Department of Planning and Environmental Protection (DPEP) described to the Cabinet members the county's plan to safely replace sand on Broward beaches lost to tidal erosion, tropical storms, and hurricanes. The project is scheduled to address severely eroded beaches in segments according to the degree of shoreline shrinkage. Somerville assured Governor Bush that Hollywood Beach, the Segment III (3) portion of the project, would start receiving sand within six months to rebuild its devastated beach.

    Broward County Commissioner Jim Scott
    Commissioner Jim Scott
    Time was equally allocated to the proponents and opponents of the project to present their final arguments to Attorney General Charlie Crist, Chief Financial Officer Tom Gallagher, Commissioner of Agriculture Charles Bronson, and Governor Jeb Bush. The Cabinet Members, having been briefed by their aides who met with the concerned parties the previous week, strictly enforced the imposed time constraints. After Steve Somerville summarized the salient aspects of the County's intentions, Broward County Commissioner Jim Scott, Hollywood Representative Eleanor Sobel, and Fort Lauderdale City Commissioner Christine Teel all voiced strong support for the project’s implementation.

    FDEP Secretary David Struhs
    Secretary David Struhs
    Pio Ieraci, who also chairs the Broward Beach Coalition, hosted an effective presentation advocating the inclusion of the Fort Lauderdale, Segment II (2), renourishment into the overall project. After explaining the need to address Fort Lauderdale’s eroded beaches, Mr. Ieraci introduced highly respected environmentalist Roy Rogers to the Cabinet. Mr. Rogers has served as the Vice Chair of the Florida Audubon Society and Vice Chair of the Florida Community Trust. In addition, he Chairs the Nature Conservancy and is the Governor's appointee to the Environmental Regulation Committee. Rogers’ portrayal of the entire project as safe, well-planned, and absolutely necessary offset claims to the contrary by project opponents. Mr. Ieraci then directed the Governor’s attention to the red tee shirted Galt Mile residents standing in the audience and introduced Eric Berkowitz as their representative. Mr. Berkowitz alerted the Cabinet to the depth of the community’s concern about losing it’s beach. David B. Struhs, Secretary of the Florida Department of Environmental Protection, exclaimed his appreciation to Mr. Berkowitz for the clear demonstration of support for the project by the Galt Mile residents.

    Governor Bush and the Cabinet voted unanimously to approve, with certain conditions, Broward County’s permit request for the entire project. The Hollywood Segment would proceed immediately. This segment would be monitored for eighteen months to assure its anticipated outcome and use any data gathered from this oversight to refine the process as applied to the Fort Lauderdale segment. The next hurdle for County officials and concerned residents is to gain the required Federal support for the project.

    Click To Top of Page


    Federal Findings Favorable

    A.C.E. Drafts Final Environmental Impact Statement


    The US Army Corps of Engineers, Jacksonville District, has completed the Final Environmental Impact Statement for Segments II and III of the Broward County Shore Protection Project. The proposed Broward County Shore Protection Project involves placement of approximately 2.5 million cubic yards of material along 11.8 miles of Broward County’s coastline. The Statement confirms that “The proposed Broward County Shore Protection Project will be in the National interest and can be constructed while protecting the environment from unacceptable impacts.” In summarizing the project's rationale, the Statement further elaborates, “Federal and County objectives include:

    1. the reduction of expected storm damages through beach nourishment and other project alternatives;
    2. reestablishing beaches as suitable recreational areas;
    3. maintaining suitable beach habitat for nesting sea turtles, invertebrate species and shorebirds; and
    4. maintaining commerce associated with beach recreation in Broward County.”

    This is good news for the millions of South Florida residents and visitors that consider the beach, which is in imminent danger of disappearing, to be an integral part of their lives.

    Port Everglades
    PORT EVERGLADES
    A contingent of Galt Mile Residents attended a May 13th Florida Cabinet meeting (Item 19 on the Agenda) in a successful effort to include Fort Lauderdale in the permit required to advance the project. The Project was approved to be completed in to parts or "Segments". The Southern part, Segment III, extends from Port Everglades through John U. Lloyd State Park, Dania Beach, Hollywood (where the beaches are already gone) and Hallandale to the Broward County/Dade County line. Work on this segment is anticipated to start in June, 2004 and continue for six months to December. A Cabinet-mandated 18 month "observation period" to assess direct, secondary and long-term effects to nearshore hardbottom habitat associated with the proposed project will commence upon completion of Segment III.
    Hillsboro Inlet
    HILLSBORO INLET
    Based upon the monitoring of these areas in Segment III, DEP would determine the likelihood for adverse impacts to the similar areas in Segment II, and recommend possible modifications and/or conditions to avoid or minimize impacts. The Segment II (Hillsboro Inlet to Port Everglades) fill will be placed along beaches in southern Pompano Beach, Lauderdale-By-The-Sea, and northern Fort Lauderdale. Segment II should subsequently start in June of 2006.

    The Final Environmental Impact Statement addresses all of the concerns expressed by an assortment of official environmental watchdog agencies in response to the original Draft Environmental Impact Statement drawn in March, 2002. The Project has garnered the support of The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), The Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP), The Broward County Department of Planning and Environmental Protection (DPEP), The National Marine and Fisheries Service (NMFS), The Florida Audubon Society, The Army Corps of Engineers, Jacksonville District Regulatory Division (ACE), The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), The Florida Communities Trust (FCT), The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FFWCC) and The Nature Conservancy.

    Timeline
     
    Projected Date Project Progress
     
    June 2004 Commence Segment III (Port Everglades to Broward/Dade County Line)
     
    December 2004 Complete Segment III - 18 Month Monitoring Period starts
     
    June 2006 18 Month Monitoring Period ends - Commence Segment II (Hillsboro Inlet to Port Everglades)

    Broward County Shore Protection Project Segments II & III Beach Fill Limits
    Broward County Shore Protection Project Segments II & III Beach Fill Limits
    The Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP), Division of Recreation and Parks, and Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FFWCC) expressed concern regarding the negative impact of the construction of T-head groin upon sea turtle nesting success and hatchling behavior, and the potential public safety hazard to recreational beach users. Since initial consultation with the FDEP, the groin field at John U. Lloyd State Park was modified from eleven (11) T-head groins to three (3) groins: two T-head structures and one spur. Appropriate sea turtle protection measures will be implemented in Broward County to minimize impacts to sea turtle hatchlings. Of course, if the beaches are permitted to disappear, there will be NO NESTING HABITAT for sea turtles.

    The FFWCC expressed concern that sand placement for the Broward County beach restoration project will result in the loss of nearshore hardbottom areas with dense coverage of marine macroalgae that has been identified as important foraging habitat for certain marine turtles. A mitigation monitoring plan has been developed and accepted by the FFWCC and FDEP that involves long-term monitoring of the mitigation reefs to determine the replacement habitat value compared to the natural nearshore hardbottom.

    The National Marine Fisheries Services (NMFS) expressed concern that several issues related to project siting, impact assessment, mitigation proposals and economic analysis were not adequately addressed in the original Draft Environmental Impact Statement. Extensive interagency coordination and additional field investigations were conducted to address the issues raised by the NMFS. The NMFS has withdrawn their opposition to the project contingent upon the construction of 11.9 acres of mitigation reef and extensive project monitoring.

    Every environmental impact raised by every mainstream environmental group has been thoroughly addressed and scrupulously responded to in this Final Impact Statement. It clearly demonstrates the Broward County plan to be safe and effective. It includes a comprehensive Cumulative Effects Assessment, a Biological Monitoring Program, turbidity monitoring, a Habitat Equivalency Analysis and a complete Nearshore Hardbottom Mitigation Plan and Shoreline Impact Analysis along with a Broward County Nearshore Hardbottom Fish Study.

    There are, however, a small number of radical fringe groups that wouldn't mind seeing our beaches melt quietly into the sea. Some of these groups have political motives behind their opposition to save the beaches. Others have financial concerns. Most of them do not live here. They have a history of making completely irrelevant and unrealistic demands on Project Coordinators, such as their insistence that florida beaches be completely rezoned prior to saving the beaches. Their stated intention is to delay and/or derail the widely supported effort to rescue Broward's eroding beaches.

    The Army Corps of Engineers is currently in the process of finalizing the documents and permits that will allow Broward County to begin the renourishment of our beaches. The Final Environmental Impact Statement was first made available for public review on January 2, 2004. This review will be completed by February 2, 2004. During this month-long process, the Broward County community has the right to comment on the plan. Once the comments are all received, the Corps will issue a final Record of Decision.

    This is your opportunity to be heard!

    Write...Fax...Email by February 2, 2004

    Please exhibit your support for the plan to save our beaches. For more information and/or to demonstrate your support, contact Ms. Terri Jordan, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Planning Division, P.O. Box 4970, Jacksonville, Florida 32232-0019, phone (904) 232-1817 or facsimile 232-3442. Ms. Jordan Can be reached by email at Terri.L.Jordan@usace.army.mil or by Clicking Here. Tell her that you support the Broward County Shore Protection Project to save our beach! Comments must be received within 30 days of publication of the Final Environmental Impact Statement in the Federal Register... That's February 2. Don't procrastinate...please act now as we are currently one hurricane away from the beach disappearing forever!

    If you are pressed for time or can't find the words to express your concern, simply fill in your name and E-Mail address and press SEND in the form below. Your message will be sent to Ms. Terri Jordan, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Planning Division. Please feel free to read the included text. To send a different message, use the E-Mail links above.

    If you prefer, you can copy and paste the message below into your favorite email program!

    Your Name

    Your E-mail Address

    Subject

    Your Message

    Click To Top of Page


    Final Record of Decision

    A.C.E. Completes ROD!


    The US Army Corps of Engineers published its completed Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS) for the Broward County Shore Protection Project, Segments II and III, in the Federal Register on January 2, 2004. The 30-day statutory waiting period which affords the public an opportunity to offer comments on the FEIS ended on February 2nd. A compilation of the collected comments called the General Reevaluation Report (GRR) was generated and attached to the FEIS. Once these two documents were reviewed, the Corps issued a Record of Decision (ROD) that serves as the final verdict in judging the efficacy, viability and advisability of the target project.

    Brigadier General Randal R. Castro, Commander, South Atlantic A.C.E. Division
    Brigadier General RANDAL R. CASTRO
    On May 13th, we received notification from the Broward County Department of Planning and Environmental Protection that the Record of Decision had been arrived at in the form of a letter from Brigadier General Randal R. Castro, South Atlantic Division Commander of the Army Corps of Engineers. The ROD is divided into 6 sections. The actual “Decision” opens the document. It reads as follows:

    “We have reviewed the General Reevaluation Report (GRR) and Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS) on the Broward County Shore Protection Project, Segments II and III, Broward County, Florida. We have also reviewed all associated correspondence, including comments on the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) and the FEIS. Based upon this review and the views of interested agencies and the concerned public, I find that the plan recommended in the GRR and FEIS by the District Engineer, Jacksonville District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps), is economically justified, technically feasible, in compliance with environmental statutes, and in the overall public interest.”

    The second section of the ROD is entitled, “Project Authority and the Need for Proposed Action”. This section explains the underlying authority that the Record of Decision and its supporting documentation is predicated on. It defines the problem as, “The coastline of Broward County is low-lying and vulnerable to storm event damages. Shoreline recession continues to be a problem along Broward County Beaches. The purpose of the GRR and FEIS was to evaluate alternatives to address these challenges and to recommend a comprehensive, cost-effective, and environmentally acceptable solution.”

    Part 3, the “Alternatives and Recommended Plan”, outlines the aspects of the project. It describes the National Economic Development Plan (NED) that was recommended by the Corps’ District Engineer and discusses several alternatives that were considered and declined. The NED covers 11.8 miles of the 24 miles of shoreline from Deerfield Beach through Hallandale and includes the following elements:

    1. Placement of 2.5 million cubic yards of material along 11.8 miles of Broward County's shoreline.
    2. Segment II (Hillsboro Inlet to Port Everglades), fill will be placed along beaches in Pompano Beach, Lauderdale-By-The-Sea and Fort Lauderdale.
    3. Segment III (Port Everglades to the south county line), fill will be placed along beaches in John U. Lloyd State Park, Dania Beach, Hollywood and Hallandale Beach.
    4. Fill will be obtained from five discrete offshore borrow areas located in the central and northern portion of the county.
    5. Development and implementation of an integrated pre- and post-construction monitoring plan was developed in close coordination with Federal and State resource agencies.

    Approximately 2.5 million cubic yards of sand would be placed for the initial construction with a total of 5.4 million cubic yards of sand needed for the life of the project.

    Fort Lauderdale’s Shrinking Ribbon of Beach
    Fort Lauderdale's Shrinking Ribbon of Beach
    Three approaches were considered in the GRR and FEIS; “no action”, structural alternatives and non-structural alternatives. “No action” achieved none of the planning objectives. The non-structural alternatives, in addition to not being economically feasible, do not address the loss of land (the existing beach) caused by long-term erosion. The structural alternative described in the NED is fiscally viable and achieves every planning objective.

    The fourth part is “Public Coordination”. The month long “comment” period from the publication of the Notice of Availability of the FEIS in the Federal Register on January 2nd elicited numerous responses from Federal, State and local government agencies, property owners, environmental organizations, and individual stakeholders. Because no new substantive issues were raised in the FEIS that weren’t previously addressed in the DEIS, the coordination with agencies and interest groups relating to project impacts and adjunctive mitigation was already adequately provided for.

    Part 5 of the Record of Decision addresses the “Factors Considered to Minimize Adverse Impacts” that may or may not surface. The most significant area of concern identified during project formulation focuses on the specific measures to offset impacts to near shore reefs and hard bottom communities. The Corps incorporated the recommendations of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), other mainstream environmental agencies, various interest groups and members of the public into the plan. The State of Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) has determined the project to be consistent with the existing Florida Coastal Management Program and, as such, issued a Joint Coastal Permit to Broward County on May 12, 2003 for both Segments II and III. To address Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) expressed a Biological Opinion designed to protect Turtles and Manatees. It produced measures that were incorporated into the plan and approved by USFWS on October 10, 2002, in the Final Coordination Act Report (CAR). Those species under the purview of the National Marine and Fisheries Service (NMFS) were provided for previously in a March 10, 2000 correspondence with the NMFS.

    Effects of Severe Tidal Erosion will be Reversed by Project
    EFFECTS OF SEVERE TIDAL EROSION WILL BE REVERSED
    The 6th and final section of the ROD is a “Summary” that reads, “In view of the above, I find that the adverse impacts of the proposed action have been minimized, to the extent practicable, and the proposed action is consonant with national policy, statutes, and administrative directives. In consideration of all pertinent factors, the overall public interest will best be served by providing the improvements as described in the General Reevaluation Report and Final Environmental Impact Statement for the Broward County Shore Protection Project.” The document is dated 11 May, 2004 and signed by “Randall R. Castro, Brigadier General, US Army, Commanding.”

    That’s it - its official - the plan has the blessing of the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, all of the environmental watchdogs with authoritative standing and the people that live on the beach. Broward County now carries the ball. They will implement the southern segment of the project first, monitor the effects for 18 months, and complete the northern portion when the southern portion receives a clean bill of health.

    The remaining obstacles to the project’s ultimate implementation are two-fold. The vested interest lobby that has supported the disappearance of the beach is still working to bring this strange aspiration to fruition. The second, more ominous, threat emanates from the United States Congress. There is a movement afoot to withdraw support for environmental programs because of fiscal constraints. The Broward County Commission has sent a letter (Click Here to View Letter) to the relevant legislators requesting that they reject any attempt to withdraw support for salvaging the nation’s beaches. That aside, the legal underpinning for the fight to rescue our beach is in place and its renourishment is simply a matter of time!

    Additional links to source information web sites:

    Click To Top of Page


    Delays and “Poison Pill” Bill
    Plague Beach Project

    Broward Finally Secures Permit


    The Broward County Department of Planning & Environmental Protection (DPEP) spent 5 years addressing the concerns of legitimate environmental groups as a statutory precursor to renourishing our disappearing Broward County beaches. Stephen Higgins, the Beach Erosion Administrator for the DPEP’s Biological Resources Division and the county’s beach renourishment director, ascribed the extensive delays to the inordinate amount of attention given the project by Federal and State Authorities. Despite widespread acceptance of the project by every major environmental group owing to Mr. Higgins’ diligence in addressing virtually all of their concerns, certain fringe elements continue their commitment to derailing the project. They have a history of making completely irrelevant and unrealistic demands on Project Coordinators, such as their insistence that Florida beaches be completely rezoned prior to saving the beaches. By delaying the project through a continuous spate of frivolous demands, they can escalate the costs. “Somehow our project has gotten more scrutiny from agencies and activist groups than any project I’ve ever seen,” explained Mr. Higgins. Total project costs have almost doubled from $30 million to $59 million, in large part from unnecessary delays.

    Hollywood Representative Eleanor Sobel
    REPRESENTATIVE
    ELEANOR SOBEL
    The latest delay resulted in the postponement of the July 1st start date for the restoration of the nearly non-existent Hollywood beaches. Angry residents and local officials are demanding an end to these capricious delays.
    Attorney General Charlie Crist
    ATTORNEY GENERAL
    CHARLIE CRIST
    State Representative Eleanor Sobel (D-Hollywood), frustrated by the project’s plodding pace, asked Florida State Attorney General Charlie Crist to look into the legitimacy of the delays. He agreed, stating “It seems like it has been an issue for quite some time.” Joann Carrin, spokeswoman for Attorney General Crist, elaborated, “We’re just looking into the whole issue, and the delays; we’re going to see what's going on.” The underlying reasons for the beach renourishment are both safety-related and financial. Broward’s share of Florida’s $15 billion beach industry is $600 million. The beach also protects billions of dollars worth of property and tens of thousands of lives exposed to severe storm event damages. Stringing out the project leaves residents and property at risk, skyrockets the cost and undermines the tourism-driven local economy.

    Brigadier General Randal R. Castro, Commander, South Atlantic A.C.E. Division
    BRIGADIER GENERAL
    RANDAL R. CASTRO
    On May 13th, exactly one year since Governor Bush and the Cabinet (including Attorney General Crist) voted unanimously to approve Broward County’s permit request for the entire project, we were notified by the Broward County Department of Planning and Environmental Protection that the Record of Decision (ROD) was received from Brigadier General Randal R. Castro, South Atlantic Division Commander of the Army Corps of Engineers.
    Colonel James G. May, Commander, Jacksonville A.C.E. Division
    COLONEL JAMES G. MAY
    In the Record of Decision (ROD) - the formal endorsement of the project by the Corps as having complied with every statute and concern raised by legitimate environmental authorities - he states, “I find that the plan recommended in the GRR (General Reevaluation Report) and FEIS (Final Environmental Impact Statement) by the District Engineer, Jacksonville District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (Corps), is economically justified, technically feasible, in compliance with environmental statutes, and in the overall public interest.” The Corps also asked that 52 additional concerns be addressed. They were.

    This heightened focus on project delays seems to have been just what the doctor ordered; the final permit to proceed was received by the DPEP on July 19th. Once the permit is executed by Broward County and Colonel James G. May, the Commander and District Engineer of the Corps’ Jacksonville District, the County can begin the bidding process for contractors, hopefully providing for a November project start date.

    Booby Trapped Beach Bill

    A serious problem has surfaced in the United States Senate. It appears that we may have to repeat the entire approval process... from scratch. The Senate Environment and Public Works Committee buried a “poison pill” into a bill labeled the “Water Resources Development Act” (WRDA), S.2554. Section 3301 mandates a rewrite of the Army Corps of Engineers policy and guidance that imposes another bureaucratic layer of restrictions on beach nourishment. Without any public testimony or hearings on the issue, a proposed Beach Nourishment Advisory Committee would be created to oversee beach projects. This new committee would create an additional layer of reviews and regulations, adding to the time and cost of each and every project. Beach projects are the ONLY projects specifically targeted in the bill for this type of micro-management by the federal government. Incomprehensibly, the language used in the legislation was submitted by an organization that is fanatically opposed to beach nourishment.

    Senate Environment and Public Works Committee
    SENATE ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE
    The “Beach Nourishment Advisory Committee” would enforce 10 specific revisions to the planning requirements imposed on the Army Corps of Engineers… only with regard to beach projects. Since every requirement is already enumerated in existing legislation, the need for another repetitive layer of governmental regulation is unclear. In addition, the committee will attempt to apply a standardized one-size-fits-all approach to many site- or state- specific conditions. For instance, Requirement #4 states that the Committee shall, “establish standards that ensure that sand deposited on replenished beaches features compatible grain size, shell content, and other geological characteristics of a natural beach”. Since every beach is different, the committee’s ultimate determination of what constitutes the generically correct grain size and shell content of a “natural beach” will be virtually useless. Site-specific considerations determine what sand characteristics are “compatible” from engineering and environmental perspectives. That decision needs to be made locally, on a beach by beach basis. This attempt to generalize standards (make the foot fit the shoe) is thematic in this legislation.

    Click to American Shore and Beach Preservation Association (ASBPA) Position Paper
    Click to ASBPA
    The American Shore and Beach Preservation Association (ASBPA), a longtime advocate of the nation’s beaches, has created a Position Paper on the proposed Beach Nourishment Advisory Committee that details the rationale for opposing its enactment. Most responsible beach communities would welcome a revision of the Corps’ policies and procedures in order to

    1. streamline the project planning process;
    2. reduce unnecessary planning costs;
    3. promote regional and/or programmatic planning where appropriate; and
    4. assure that any short- and long-term environmental impacts of beach nourishment projects are benign.

    The “poison pill” that was unceremoniously dumped into the Senate’s WRDA bill, however, accomplishes NONE of these objectives.

    Click to American Shore and Beach Preservation Association (ASBPA) Position Paper
    Click to American Shore and Beach
    Preservation Association Position Paper
    Positioned in Senate Bill S.2554 under Title III—Flood and Coastal Storm Damage Reduction, Subtitle B--Coastal Storm Damage Reduction, Section 3301—Shore Protection and Beach Renourishment Projects, the section’s specific provisions are drawn from anecdotal “evidence” which ignores that the Corps already addresses each of the concerns raised in this provision. Without any public testimony, discussion, or any evidence of need, the legislation establishes an advisory committee that will not advise, but rather enforce the redundant requirements in 10 specific areas that are already addressed in existing legislation. In addition to lacking a provision to finance the costs of this committee (another visit to Unfunded Mandate-ville), the decisions of the advisory committee would apply to all existing draft feasibility studies and draft re-evaluation reports that have not yet been issued. This means that studies that have been produced under one set of procedures over a period of several years will have to be redone with the revised regulations, guidelines, and circulars. This retroactive application could effectively double feasibility costs and timetables for all existing projects. Nothing in the provision requires that advisory committee members have water resources planning expertise, nor does the provision include a representative of the Corps of Engineers. Should the unamended legislation be enacted, the cost of beach projects would increase substantially as will their impending timetables due to the responsible lead agencies having to slug their way through another unnecessary layer of redundant governmental regulations.

    Please Take a Moment to Avoid a Nightmare

    Senator Bob Graham
    Senator Bob Graham
    Senator William Nelson
    Senator William Nelson
    The overt inadequacies and the surprise addition of this unsupported provision becloud the intentions of the Senators that allowed its inclusion. Motives aside, the American Shore and Beach Preservation Association (ASBPA) and the Florida Shore & Beach Preservation Association (FSBPA) strongly advocate that the establishment of a beach nourishment advisory committee is NOT the appropriate tactic to resolve concerns with the existing process and urge that it be removed from the bill prior to Senate passage.

    The Galt Mile Community Association agrees and asks each of its members to contact their Senators and urge the removal of this section from the bill. The idea of re-experiencing the past 5 years of scrupulously performed feasibility studies to accommodate a suspicious and poorly conceived legislative midnight surprise passes from the ridiculous to the sublime. Please contact Senators Graham and Nelson by email and telephone to let them know that the WRDA bill must be improved through the removal of Section 3301 (Click and Scroll Down to 3301). (Senator Graham, incidentally, is a member of the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee.) As conscientious Florida officials, they are keenly aware of the importance of maintaining the beaches that underwrite our economy. If they receive a reasonable indication of our concerns, they will fight to excise this “Poison Pill”.

    • Click Here to send an email to Senator Graham. Please follow-up with a phone call to Graham’s office: Bob Dobek with Senator Graham (202) 224-3041 - Local Tel # is: (305) 536-7293.
    • Click Here to send an email to Senator Nelson. Please follow-up with a phone call to Nelson’s office: (202) 224-5274 - Local Tel # is: (305) 536-5999, 1 (888) 671-4091.

    The Easy Way

    If you don't have the time or inclination to compose an email, you can send one that has already been composed for this purpose! Using this contact will send emails to Senator Graham and Senator Nelson with one click.

    • Simply Click Here if you live on the Galt Mile (in the 33308 ZIP code).
    • If you live anywhere else, please Click Here, then enter your ZIP code and click.

    The American Shore and Beach Preservation Association (ASBPA) has developed a Position Paper that clearly addresses the issues at stake. To read the text of the “Poison Pill”, along with detailed explanations refuting the efficacy of each provision, Click Here.

    To read the text of the “Poison Pill”, Click Here. (Scroll down to Section 3301 and click!)

    Click To Top of Page


    Where’s the Beach

    Hurricane Frances Carries a Warning


    Hollywood Mayor Mara Giulianti
    Mayor Giulianti
    Hollywood
    Mayor Mara Giulianti, comporting herself as a sensitively empathetic municipal guardian during a real life natural disaster, responded succinctly to her interviewer from channel 10, “Well, the situation is extremely dangerous because there is no beach to buffer us from the effects of the storm.” POINT TAKEN! Hurricane Frances was skirting its North Palm Beach landfall at about 4:30 PM Saturday afternoon as her live interview hit the air. The cameras caught sections of Surf Road just south of Dania Boulevard actually dissolving during the Mayor’s evaluation of the damages suffered along the vulnerable beach. The beaches in Hollywood disappeared several years ago, the victim of sustained tidal erosion. The condition is mirrored up and down the East Coast of Broward, as 21 of the 24 miles of the County’s beaches are critically eroded. In 1999, Broward County put the recovery process into motion, hoping to repair the deteriorating shoreline within the two - three year window that a safe, responsible beach renourishment would normally take. Every major environmental agency and organization took the opportunity to institute extensive protective measures and exigent monitoring requirements as the Broward County Department of Planning and Environmental Protection (DPEP), Biological Resources Division carefully steered the plan through its statutory paces in an effort to rescue the beach.